Philosophy of the Sciences and Mathematics

PHILOSOPHY OF THE SCIENCES AND MATHEMATICS

General Philosophy of Science

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
University of California, Irvine4.54.54.5,5.01
University of Pittsburgh4.54.551
Cambridge University4442
Carnegie Mellon University4442
London School of Economics4452
New York University4442
Stanford University4442
University of Bristol4442
University of California, San Diego444.52
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor444.52
University of Notre Dame4442
University of Sydney4442
University of Wisconsin, Madison4442
Australian National University3.5443
Columbia University3.5433
Duke University3.53.533
Indiana University, Bloomington3.53.533
Oxford University3.53.543
University of British Columbia3.53.543
University of Durham3.5443
University of Leeds3.53.533
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul3.53.543
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill3.53.543
University of Pennsylvania3.53.533
University of Toronto3.5443
University of Utah3.53.533
University of Western Ontario3.53.7543
City University of New York Graduate Center3334
Florida State University3334
Johns Hopkins University32.752.0,3.04
King's College, London3334
Ohio State University3334
Princeton University3334
Rutgers University, New Brunswick3334
University of Arizona3344
University of Calgary33.544
University of California, Davis3334
University of Edinburgh332.5,4.04
University of Maryland, College Park3334
University of Miami3334
University of Southern California3334
Washington University St. Louis3334

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Ludwig Maximillian University, Munich Center for Mathematical Philosophy, University of Exeter, University of Groningen, University of South Carolina

Evaluators: Anna Alexandrova, Andre Ariew, Brad Armendt, Jeffrey Barrett, John Bickle, Alexander Bird, David Braddon-Mitchell, Mazviita Chirimuuta, David Danks, Shamik Dasgupta, Stephen Downes, Marc Ereshefsky, Ken Gemes, Paul Griffiths, Gary Gutting, William Harper, David Hilbert, Chris Hitchcock, Simon Hutteger, Jim Joyce, Elisabeth Lloyd, Edouard Machery, Dominic Murphy, Daniel Nolan, Jill North, John Norton, Samir Okasha, Richard Pettigrew, A. Rosenberg, Paul Roth, Howard Sankey, Wilfried Sieg, Brian Skyrms, Chris Smeenk, Sonja Smets, Kyle Stanford, Kim Sterelny, Michael Strevens, J.D. Trout, Michael Weisberg, Eric Winsberg, Christian Wuthrich.

Philosophy of Physics

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
Oxford University5551
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor5551
New York University4.54.54.52
University of California, Irvine4.5552
University of Southern California4.5442
University, of California, San Diego4.54.54.52
Cambridge University43.754.53
Columbia University44.54.5,5.03
London School of Economics4443
University of Arizona443.5,4.03
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul443.5,4.03
University of Pittsburgh44.553
University of Western Ontario4443
Princeton University 3.53.7544
Stanford University3.53.52.0,3.5,4.04
University of Bristol3.544.0,4.54
University of Illinois, Chicago3.53.53.5,4.04
University of Maryland, College Park3.532.54
Boston University333.0,3.55
Duke University32.752.5,3.55
Johns Hopkins University332.55
King's College, London3335
Rutgers University, New Brunswick3335
University of Leeds3345
University of North Carolin, Chapel Hill332.0,3.0,4.05
University of Notre Dame3335

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Ludwig Maximillian University, Munich Center for Mathematical Philosophy, University of South Carolina

Evaluators: Jeffrey Barrett, David Braddon-Mitchell, Shamik Dasgupta, Stephen Downes, William Harper, Nicholas Huggett, Oliver Pooley, Chris Smeenk, Sonja Smets, Michael Strevens, Jill North, John Norton, David Wallace, Eric Winsberg, Christian Wuthrich.

Philosophy of Biology

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
Australian National University4.5551
Duke University4.5441
University of Sydney4.5551
University of Bristol4442
University of Calgary44.54.0,4.52
University of California, Davis4442
University of Pittsburgh43.53.52
University of Utah4442
University of Wisconsin, Madison444.0,5.02
University of British Columbia3.53.53.53
University of California, Irvine3.5443
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul3.53.7543
University of Pennsylvania3.53.543
University of Toronto3.53.53.53
Arizona State University33.544
Cambridge University33.2544
Columbia University33.251.0,3.0,3.5,5.04
Florida State University3334
Indiana University, Bloomington33.544
University of Leeds333.0,4.04
University of Texas, Austin331.0,3.04
Washington University St. Louis3334

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: University of Cincinnati, University of Exeter

Evaluators: Andre Ariew, John Bickle, David Braddon-Mitchell, Mazviita Chirimuuta, Stephen Downes, Marc Ereshefsky, Paul Griffiths, Elisabeth Lloyd, Edouard Machery, Mohan Matthen, Dominic Murphy, Bence Nanay, Samir Okasha, A. Rosenberg, Paul Roth, Chris Smeenk, Kyle Stanford, Kim Sterelny, Michael Weisberg, Robert Wilson.

Philosophy of Social Sciences

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
University of Durham4.54.551
Carnegie Mellon University442.0,3.5,4.5,5.02
London School of Economics44.552
Stanford University4442
University of Arizona44.53.0,4.5,5.02
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor44.254.52
University of Pennsylvania443.0,4.0,4.52
University of Pittsburgh4442
University of Wisconsin, Madison4452
Australian National University3.5443
Columbia University3.53.252.5,4.03
Duke University 3.542.5,4.03
Harvard University3.52.752.53
Princeton University3.53.52.5,3.0,4.0,4.53
University of Bristol3.53.53.53
University of British Columbia3.5333
University of California, Irvine3.5443
University of Sydney3.53.252.0,3.0,3.5,5.03
Birkbeck College, University of London32.752.5,4.04
Cambridge University32.751.5,2.5,3.0,5.04
City University of New York Graduate Center3334
Massachusetts Institute of Technology331.5,2.0,3.0,3.5,4.04
New York University332.0,3.0,3.54
Oxford University332.0,3.0,4.04
Rutgers University, New Brunswick3334
University of California, San Diego3334
University of Nebraska, Lincoln3334
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill33.253.54
Washington University St. Louis33.544

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: University of Exeter, University of Kentucky

Evaluators: Anna Alexandrova, Cristina Bicchieri, Stephen Downes, Dominic Murphy, Alexander Prescott-Couch, A. Rosenberg, Paul Roth, David Schmidtz, J.D. Trout, Somogy Varga.

Philosophy of Cognitive Science

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
University of Pittsburgh4.54.551
City University of New York Graduate Center44.254.0,5.02
New York University44.552
Rutgers University, New Brunswick44.552
University of Arizona444.52
University of California, San Diego4442
University of Edinburgh444.5,5.02
University of Sydney4442
Washington University St. Louis4442
Australian National University3.53.253.0,4.03
Duke University3.5443
University of British Columbia3.5443
University of Maryland, College Park3.53.53.53
University of Toronto3.53.533
University of Western Ontario3.5333
Yale University3.53.53.53
Carnegie Mellon University33.53.54
Columbia University333.54
Monash University33.53.5,4.04
Ohio State University3334
Princeton University3334
University of California, Berkeley33.252.5,3.0,3.5,4.54
University of California, Los Angeles33.544
University of California, Riverside3324
University of Miami3334
University of Pennsylvania3334
University of Wisconsin, Madison3334
York University, Toronto3334

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Macquarie University, Simon Fraser University, University of Adelaide, University of Cincinnati

Evaluators: Avery Archer, Murat Aydede, John Bickle, David Braddon-Mitchell, Berit Brogaard, Peter Carruthers, Mazviita Chirimuuta, Kevin Connolly, David Danks, Jake Davis, John Doris, Stephen Downes, Frances Egan, Rocco Gennaro, Alvin Goldman, Paul Griffiths, David Hilbert, Anne Jacobson, Ernest LePore, Edouard Machery, Ronald Mallon, Brian McLaughlin, Friederike Moltmann, Dominic Murphy, Bence Nanay, Gualtiero Piccinini, Michael Rescorla, Richard Samuels, Chris Smeenk, Robert Stainton, Kim Sterelny, Stephen Stich, Michael Strevens, J.D. Trout, Somogy Varga, Jonathan Weinberg, Robert Wilson.

Decision, Rational Choice, & Game Theory

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
Carnegie Mellon University4.5551
London School of Economics4.54.551
University of California, Irvine4.5551
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor4.54.551
Australian National University4442
Stanford University4442
University of Bristol4442
University of Pennsylvania4442
Arizona State University33.53.53
Cambridge University33.52.0,3.5,4.03
Columbia University332.5,3.0,3.53
Harvard University3333
Massachusetts Institute of Technology32.52.53
New York University333.53
Notre Dame University3343
Oxford University33.2523
Princeton University333.0,3.53
Rutgers University, New Brunswick3343
Texas A&M University33.53.53
University of California, Berkeley33.53.53
University of Maryland, College Park3333
University of Missouri, Columbia3333
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill332.5,3.0,4.03
University of Pittsburgh3343
University of Southern California333.53
University of Toronto3333
University of Utah3333
University of Wisconsin, Madison3333

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Ludwig Maximillian University, Munich Center for Mathematical Philosophy

Evaluators: Anna Alexandrova, Brad Armendt, Jeffrey Barrett, Cristina Bicchieri, Lara Buchak, Mazviita Chirimuuta, David Danks, Stephen Downes, Gerald Gaus, Anthony Gillies, William Harper, Chris Hitchcock, Simon Hutteger, Jim Joyce, John Norton, Samir Okasha, Richard Pettigrew, Wlodek Rabinowicz, David Schmidtz, Wilfried Sieg, Brian Skyrms, Chris Smeenk, Sonja Smets, Kim Sterel

Philosophy of Mathematics

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
University of California, Irvine5551
Carnegie Mellon University4.5552
Harvard University4.54.552
Ohio State University4.54.552
Oxford University4.5552
Princeton University4.54.54.0,5.02
University of Notre Dame4.5442
City University of New York Graduate Center4443
Massachusetts Institute of Technology4443
McGill University4443
New York University44.553
University of California, Berkeley444.0,5.03
University of California, Los Angeles4443
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul4443
University of Sydney4443
Brown University3.53.754.0,5.04
University of Bristol3.543.0,4.0,4.54
University of Connecticut, Storrs3.5444
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor3.53.53.0,4.04
University of Pittsburgh3.5444
University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program3.53.53.0,4.04
Boston University32.752.0,2.5,4.55
Cambridge University3335
Columbia University33.545
Cornell University3345
Stanford University331.0,3.0,4.0,5.05
Texas A&M University333.55
University of Calgary3345
University of California, Davis3335
University of California, Riverside331.5,3.0,4.05
University of Melbourne322.0,4.05
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill3335
University of Toronto3335
University of Western Ontario33.2545
Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board

Evaluators: Jeffrey Barrett, Warren Goldfarb, William Harper, Leon Horsten, Robin Jeshion, Mary Leng, Penelope Maddy, Edwin Mares, Robert May, Calvin Normore, John Norton, Ian Rumfitt, Wilfried Sieg, Chris Smeenk, Timothy Williamson.

Mathematical Logic

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
Carnegie Mellon University5551
Harvard University5551
City University of New York Graduate Center4.54.552
Ohio State University4443
Princeton University443.0,5.03
University of Bristol4443
University of California, Berkeley44.553
University of California, Irvine44.553
Columbia University3.53.544
Cornell University3.544.0,5.04
New York University3.533.0,4.5,5.04
Oxford University3.532.5,5.04
Stanford University3.543.0,4.0,5.04
University of California, Los Angeles3.5444
University of Leeds3.53.251.5,5.04
University of Notre Dame3.5444
Boston University332.0,3.0,5.05
Indiana University, Bloomington333.0,4.05
Massachusetts Institute of Technology33.545
University of Calgary32.752.0,2.5,3.05
University of Connecticut, Storrs33.52.0,4.0,5.05
University of Melbourne32.50.0,1.5,2.0,2.5,4.0,4.5,5.05
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul33.51.0,4.05
University of Pittsburgh332.55
University of Toronto3335
University of Western Ontario340.0,5.05
Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board:
Ludwig Maximillian University, Munich Center for Mathematical Philosophy
Simon Fraser University
University of Adelaide

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Ludwig Maximillian University, Munich Center for Mathematical Philosophy; Simon Fraser University; University of Adelaide

Evaluators: Jeffrey Barrett, Warren Goldfarb, Wesley Holliday, Leon Horsten, John Horty, Thomas Icard, John Kearns, Penelope Maddy, Edwin Mares, Robert May, Friederike Moltmann, Calvin Normore, Peter Pagin, Richard Pettigrew, Wilfried Sieg, Chris Smeenk.