Metaphysics & Epistemology

METAPHYSICS & EPISTEMOLOGY

PHILOSOPHY OF LANGUAGE

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
New York University4.54.551
Rutgers University, New Brunswick4.5551
University of Southern California4.54.551
Yale University4.54.551
City University of New York Graduate Center4452
Massachusetts Institute of Technology44.254.52
Oxford University 44.552
University of California, Berkeley44.552
University of California, Los Angeles44.552
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor4442
University of Pittsburgh4442
University of Texas, Austin4442
University of Toronto443.5,4.02
Brown University3.53.543
Columbia University3.5443
Harvard University3.53.54.53
Northwestern University3.53.553
Stanford University3.53.7543
University College London3.5333
University of California, Santa Barbara3.5443
University of Connecticut, Storrs3.53.53.53
University of Edinburgh3.53.2543
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill3.5333
University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program3.53.543
Cambridge University3334
Cornell University32.7524
Indiana University, Bloomington333.0,3.54
King's College, London3324
Monash University32.53.54
Princeton University33.2544
University of Arizona33.2544
University at Buffalo3334
University of California, Davis3344
University of California, San Diego3344
University of Colorado, Boulder3334
University of Leeds3334
University of Massachusetts, Amherst3334
University of Miami3334
University of Notre Dame33.53.54
University of Reading332.0,3.54
University of Sheffield332.0,3.0,3.5,4.0,5.04
University of Western Ontario32.7524

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board

Evaluators: David Braddon-Mitchell, David Braun, Berit Brogaard, Jonathan Cohen, Keith DeRose, Anthony Gillies, John Hawthorne, Benjamin Hellie, Robin Jeshion, Jeffrey King, Frederick Kroon, Ernest LePore, Bernard Linsky, Edwin Mares, Robert May, Alex Miller, Friederike Moltmann, Peter Pagin, David Pitt, Ian Rumfitt, Joseph Salerno, Nathan Salmon, Stephen Schiffer, Susanna Siegel, David Sosa, Robert Stainton, Kim Sterelny, Charles Travis, John Turri, Timothy Williamson, Jose Zalabardo.

PHILOSOPHY OF MIND

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
New York University5551
Rutgers University, New Brunswick4.54.552
City University of New York Graduate Center44.54.53
Columbia University4443
Massachusetts Institute of Technology4443
University of California, Berkeley4443
University of California, Los Angeles4443
University of Pittsburgh4443
University of Texas, Austin4443
University of Toronto443.53
Australian National University3.53.544
Brown University 3.53.544
Harvard University 3.5444
King's College, London3.53.53.54
Monash University3.53.53.0,4.04
Oxford University3.5334
Princeton University3.53.53.54
University of Arizona3.5444
University of Birmingham3.53.544
University of British Columbia3.53.544
University of California, San Diego3.53.544
University of Edinburgh3.53.534
University of Maryland, College Park3.5334
University of Massachusetts, Amherst3.53.53.54
University of Sydney3.53.53.54
Washington University St. Louis3.5444
Yale University3.5334
Cornell University3335
Duke University3335
Ohio State University3325
Rice University3335
Stanford University3335
Syracuse University3335
University of California, Riverside3335
University of Connecticut, Storrs3335
University of Glasgow3345
University of Miami3345
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill3335
University of Notre Dame332.5,3.05
University of Sheffield3335
University of Southern California3345
University of Virginia3335
University of Warwick333.0,3.55
University of Western Ontario333.55
University of Wisconsin, Madison3335
Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board
Central European University
Simon Fraser University
University of Arkansas
University of Cincinnati

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Central European University, Simon Fraser University, University of Arkansas, University of Cincinnati

Evaluators: Torin Alter, Avery Archer, Murat Aydede, John Bengson, Paul Boghossian, David Bourget, David Braddon-Mitchell, Bill Brewer, Berit Brogaard, Alex Byrne, Peter Carruthers, Mazviita Chirimuuta, Jonathan Cohen, Kevin Connolly, Gregory Currie, Jake Davis, John Doris, Stephen Downes, Frances Egan, Rocco Gennaro, Alvin Goldman, John Hawthorne, Benjamin Hellie, David Hilbert, Christopher Hill, Anne Jacobson, Robin Jeshion, Uriah Kriegel, Ernest LePore, Edouard Machery, Mohan Matthen, Brian McLaughlin, Angela Mendelovici, Friederike Moltmann, Michelle Montague, John Morrison, Dominic Murphy, Bence Nanay, Timothy O’Connor, Derk Pereboom, Gualtiero Piccinini, David Pitt, Michael Rescorla, Joseph Salerno, Richard Samuels, Susanna Siegel, David Sosa, Ernest Sosa, Robert Stainton, Kim Sterelny, Stephen Stich, Charles Travis, John Turri, Robert Wilson, Jose Zalabardo.

METAPHYSICS

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
New York University5551
Rutgers University, New Brunswick5551
University of Southern California4.54.542
Massachusetts Institute of Technology443.53
Oxford University44.553
Princeton University4443
University of Notre Dame4443
University of Virginia443.5,4.03
Columbia University3.53.53.0,4.04
Cornell University3.53.544
Syracuse University3.53.544
University of Arizona3.53.544
University of California, Berkeley3.5444
University of Leeds3.5444
University of Manchester3.53.53.0,4.04
University of Massachusetts, Amherst3.53.544
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor3.53.544
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill3.53.53.54
University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program3.53.534
University of Toronto3.53.53.54
Australian National University3335
Cambridge University3335
City University of New York Graduate Center33.545
King's College, London3335
University of Birmingham333.0,4.05
University of California, Davis332.55
University of California, Santa Barbara33.2535
University of Colorado, Boulder332.5,3.0,3.55
University of Connecticut, Storrs332.5,3.0,3.55
University of Durham32.52.55
University of Nottingham3335
University of Pittsburgh332.5,3.05
University of Sydney3335
University of Texas, Austin333.0,4.05
Washington University St. Louis3335
Yale University332.55

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Trinity College Dublin

Evaluators: John Bengson, Alexander Bird, David Braddon-Mitchell, Bill Brewer, Javier Cumpa, Shamik Dasgupta, John Hawthorne, Benjamin Hellie, Robin Jeshion, Dan Kaufman, Uriah Kriegel, Bernard Linsky, Matt McGrath, Friederike Moltmann, Daniel Nolan, Timothy O’Connor, David Pitt, Michael Della Rocca, Joseph Salerno, Nathan Salmon, Carolina Sartorio, Ted Sider,  Susanna Siegel, Ernest Sosa, Robert Stainton, Charles Travis, Gabriel Uzquiano, Timothy Williamson, Christian Wuthrich, Jose Zalabardo, Dean Zimmerman.

EPISTEMOLOGY

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
New York University4.54.54.51
Oxford University4.54.551
Rutgers University, New Brunswick4.5551
Yale University4.5441
Princeton University4442
University of Arizona4442
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor4442
University of Southern California4442
Massachusetts Institute of Technology3.53.533
Northwestern University3.5443
Stanford University3.53.543
University of California, Irvine3.5443
University of California, Los Angeles3.53.533
University of Massachusetts, Amherst3.53.543
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill3.5443
University of Notre Dame3.53.53.0,4.03
University of Pittsburgh3.53.533
University of Rochester3.53.543
University of Toronto3.53.53.53
University of Wisconsin, Madison3.5333
Australian National University332.0,3.0,4.04
Brown University3334
Carnegie Mellon University32.7524
City University of New York Graduate Center3334
Columbia University3334
Harvard University33.53.0,3.54
Indiana University , Bloomington3334
King's College, London33.53.0,3.54
London School of Economics3324
Saint Louis University333.54
Texas A&M University3334
University of Birmingham3334
University of British Columbia3334
University of California, Berkeley3334
University of Colorado, Boulder33.53.54
University of Edinburgh33.544
University of Glasgow3334
University of Miami3334
University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program33.53.54
University of Texas, Austin3334
Washington University St. Louis3334

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Baylor University, Fordham University, Loyola University, Chicago, Ludwig Maximillian University, Munich Center for Mathematical Philosophy

Evaluators: Brad Armendt, Jeffrey Barrett, John Bengson, Sven Bernecker, Cristina Bicchieri, Alexander Bird, Paul Boghossian, David Braddon-Mitchell, Berit Brogaard, Lara Buchak, Alex Byrne, Juan Comesaña, Keith DeRose, Stephen Downes, Jeremy Fantl, Anthony Gillies, Alvin Goldman, John Greco, Stephen Grimm, John Hawthorne, David Hilbert, Michael Huemer, Simon Hutteger, Robin Jeshion, Jim Joyce, Peter Klein, Jennifer Lackey, Kevin Mccain, Matt McGrath, Jennifer Nagel, Ram Neta, John Norton, Samir Okasha, David Pitt, Duncan Pritchard, Wlodek Rabinowicz, Michael Rescorla, Paul Roth, Joseph Salerno, Susanna Siegel, Sonja Smets, Nicholas Smith, David Sosa, Ernest Sosa, Robert Stainton, Kim Sterelny, Matthias Steup, Stephen Stich, Charles Travis, J.D. Trout, John Turri, Somogy Varga, Ted Warfield, Jonathan Weinberg, Timothy Williamson, Jose Zalabardo.

Philosophical Logic

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
City University of New York Graduate Center4.54.551
New York University4.5551
Oxford University4.5551
University of California, Berkeley4.54.54.5,5.01
Carnegie Mellon University4452
Harvard University4442
Massachusetts Institute of Technology4442
Monash University44.2552
Ohio State University443.0,4.0,5.02
Princeton University44.2552
Stanford University444.0,4.52
University of California, Los Angeles444.0,4.52
University of Connecticut, Storrs444.0,5.02
University of Melbourne4442
University of Notre Dame44.254.52
University of Pittsburgh4432
University of Southern California4432
University of St. Andrews/Stirling Joint Program4442
University of Texas, Austin4442
Brown University3.53.53.0,4.53
Cambridge University3.543.0,4.0,4.53
Columbia University3.53.53.53
Indiana University, Bloomington3.53.543
Northwestern University3.53.543
Texas A&M University3.5443
University of Bristol3.5443
University of Calgary3.53.2543
University of California, Irvine3.5443
University of California, Santa Barbara3.53.533
University of Leeds3.53.2533
University of Maryland, College Park3.53.51.0,3.0,4.0,5.03
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor3.5443
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill3.53.543
University of Toronto3.5443
Victoria University, Wellington3.53.52.5,3.53
Australian National University3344
Cornell University3344
London School of Economics333.0,3.54
Rutgers University, New Brunswick33.544
University of Alberta3334
University of Auckland331.0,3.0,3.5,4.04
University of Birmingham3444
University of California, San Diego32.752.5,4.04
University of Colorado, Boulder332.5,3.04
University of Edinburgh32.751.0,2.54
University of Glasgow330.0,3.54
University of Massachusetts, Amherst32.544
University of Miami331.0,3.0,3.5,4.04
University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul33.2544
University of Nottingham3344
University of Sheffield33.53.54
University of Sydney3324
University of Western Ontario3344
Washington University St. Louis33.544
Yale University332.0,5.04

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Baylor University

Evaluators: Jeffrey Barrett, David Braddon-Mitchell, Anthony Gillies, Warren Goldfarb, Wesley Holliday, Leon Horsten, John Horty, Thomas Icard, John Kearns, Philip Kremer, Frederick Kroon, Bernard Linsky, Edwin Mares, Robert May, Daniel Nolan, Peter Pagin, Wlodek Rabinowicz, Ian Rumfitt, Joseph Salerno, Nathan Salmon, Wilfried Sieg, Sonja Smets, Charles Travis, Gabriel Uzquiano, Timothy Williamson.

Philosophy of Action

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
Florida State University4.544.0,5.01
University of California, Riverside4442
Cornell University3.53.2533
Stanford University3.53.52.5,4.03
University of Arizona3.53.52.5,3.5,4.53
University of California, San Diego3.53.752.0,4.03
University of Notre Dame3.53.53.53
University of Southern California3.543.0,4.0,4.53
Brown University332.0,3.0,4.04
Cambridge University3334
Duke University3334
King's College, London3334
Massachusetts Institute of Technology3344
New York University332.5,3.04
Oxford University3334
Princeton University33.2544
Rice University3334
University of California, Berkeley3334
University of California, Los Angeles32.52.54
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor331.5,4.04
University of Pittsburgh32.524
University of Texas, Austin32.752.5,3.04
University of Toronto332.0,3.04

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Baylor University, Simon Fraser University

Evaluators: Avery Archer, John Bengson, Michael McKenna, Alfred Mele, Timothy O’Connor, Paul Roth, Carolina Sartorio, Manuel Vargas, Ted Warfield, Gideon Yaffe.

Philosophy of Religion

InstitutionRounded MeanMedianMode(s)Group
University of Notre Dame4.54.54.0,5.01
Saint Louis University 44.552
Oxford University3.5443
Purdue University3.53.753.0,4.03
Rutgers University, New Brunswick3.53.2533
Monash University3334
University of Southern California3334
Yale University32.52.54

Additional programs not evaluated this year but recommended for consideration by the Advisory Board: Baylor University, Fordham University, University of New england (Australia), University of Oklahoma, Norman

Evaluators: Lara Buchak, Stephen Grimm, Gary Gutting, Brian Leftow, Timothy O’Connor, Graham Oppy, Derk Pereboom, Eleonore Stump, Ted Warfield, Dean Zimmerman.